2012年5月2日星期三

Shifting Perspectives: Tanks, bribes, and player behavior

As the majority of you are possibly aware, Blizzard recently announced a producer new incentive framework for the dungeon finder method recognised since the phone call to Arms. In essence, it added benefits gamers for executing what is then the most-needed part even although in the dungeon finder using a BoA bag that contains gold, flasks, and, potentially, mounts and pets.

I do believe that developers are struggling to offer using a concern designed and driven almost completely by participant behavior. Latest heroics aren't fun, not offered how the content substance is bad or overtuned, but Cataclysm combines components in the Burning Crusade and Wrath in the Lich King 5-man knowing that don't hold out nicely with every other. The dungeon finder contributes to these problems, but not even although in the way in which that you'd think.

The Burning Crusade and heroic difficulty
When heroics experienced been introduced even although in the Burning Crusade, 5-man tanking wasn't something you do for fun. Pulls experienced been large, as well as really a few in the mobs experienced competencies made to wipe inattentive groups.

However, what was gratifying was acquiring a reputation in your server like a experienced tank. Logging on and right away receiving a slew of requests for heroic runs felt great. Even although it didn't make tanking the much more vicious BC heroics any simpler or much more enjoyable, getting recognised as somebody who could hold out these instances using the ability of the virtuoso was tremendously appealing. One of my proudest in-game moments was seeing somebody write, "I have certainly not wiped with Allison tanking" on my realm boards in the thread searching for 5-man tanks.

And it experienced been superb which you obtained some validation from fellow players, offered that frankly, there weren't lots of factors that experienced been objectively gratifying about tanking in the time.  Warriors and paladins experienced the one-two whammy of limited farming potential and monstrous fix bills. Druids and warriors went loony attempting to sustain aggro in dungeons like Shattered Halls and Shadow Lab. Itemization sucked for the two "hybrid tanks" for the time period in the game. Paladins literally do not possess just one weapon designed for their use previous the ilevel 115 Crystalforged Sword, and also this column's addressed the concern of BC bear itemization.

The Wrath type and intro in the dungeon finder
Most gamers are common using the troubles that resulted from the confluence of factors in Wrath in the Lich King. In short, buffs to DPS and tanking specs' AoE competencies in tandem with simpler heroics common decreased most heroics to runs precisely where pace was prioritized over skill.

Tanks executing their normal heroic with arbitrary groups lost the probability to create a server-wide reputation, but nobody observed anticipated toward the ease in the common 5-man. You don't create a reputation away something that's not that challenging to begin with, and team quality's almost a non-issue in any context precisely where you're not dependent in your DPS for crowd control. A awesome tank all through the Wrath era wasn't somebody with reliability pulling method or an experienced eyesight for marking. A awesome tank was somebody who pulled as quickly as possible, offered the limits of her or his gear, to possess the ability to preempt the common "Gogogogo!" cry. Offered that Blizzard experienced eliminated the really a few annoyances outlined above, tanking was also a complete whole lot much more gratifying on its individual merits. You can blast by method of a heroic safe even although in the knowing that inexperienced or undergeared DPS exercised almost no effect near to the outcome.

Cataclysm: trouble brewing
The dungeon finder is maybe much more suited to some world with higher margin for team error. Tanks are usually unwilling to confront instances requiring heavy crowd control once they don't know what sort of team they're going to get. Guild accomplishments and reputation are also oriented near to guildies' instancing together. I wouldn't go so much concerning say how the dungeon finder will can be found to be obsolete, but I'm reasonably particular how the wait around for just about any tank is going to acquire longer. When CC is much more of the concern, a tank's control over the dungeon's end result is necessarily limited, and there are progressively many incentives to ply your industry for just about any arbitrary group.

The possible troubles designed by this method to 5-man content substance started to can be found to be obvious even although in the Cataclysm beta as Blizzard returned toward the much more challenging BC instancing model, and that's the circumstance by which we locate ourselves today. Trash is harder, and trash mobs are much more numerous. Mobs and bosses have nasty competencies requiring groups to interrupt and hold out cautiously. Crowd control and cautious pulling are required. In short, DPSers have much more obligation for the accomplishment in the dungeon, just as tanks have much more obligation for directing the team. And tanks have responded by leaving the dungeon finder in droves.

The higher the obligation offered to DPSers in arbitrary 5-mans, the much less incentive that tanks and healers should run with something other than a guild group. Even although the most recent dungeon finder doesn't trigger this behavior, it undoubtedly allows it.
Source: http://faithfeed.me/zengyw011
http://zoov.co/zengyw011
http://icets.info/share/zengyw011
http://www.unanaija.com/zengyw011
http://www.gharaibehweb.com/share/zengyw011
http://yourmeadville.com/community/zengyw011
http://hicrony.com/zengyw011

没有评论:

发表评论